Many Catholics who were better and longer formed in the Faith than your blogmaster was in 1970 (when he was receiving his first Holy Communion at age seven) probably had a sense that the Church was on the cusp of a generation of liturgical turmoil, even if they didn’t have a sense of how very badly worship would be distorted at certain times and places.
In that year Dr. Eric de Saventhem, first president of the International Federation Una Voce, expressed a vision for the future that was by no means as grim as others’ might have been:
A renaissance will come: asceticism and adoration as the mainspring of direct total dedication to Christ will return. Confraternities of priests, vowed to celibacy and to an intense life of prayer and meditation will be formed. Religious will regroup themselves into houses of strict observance. A new form of Liturgical Movement will come into being, led by young priests and attracting mainly young people, in protest against the flat, prosaic, philistine or delirious liturgies which will soon overgrow and finally smother even the recently revised rites.
If you agree that the renaissance is well under way, you may yet wonder whether the renewed sprouting of traditional liturgy is attracting worshipers to the pews — or driving them away. Many readers of Fr. Z’s Blog have recently been sharing their diverse and occasionally surprising experiences as either a new or established attendee at the revivified TLM.